Award-winning Chicago-area social media agency focused on building authentic communities and turning followers into brand advocates.
Fresh Content Society is a leading paid and organic social media agency that helps clients achieve their business goals through social media. They specialize in growing social media communities for brands, delivering fresh strategy, content, engagement, and campaigns, all backed by data to provide real-time ROI. With expertise in social media strategy, content, and growth, they partner with businesses to boost their social media presence.
Our take on Fresh Content Society
Fresh Content Society (FCS) has emerged as one of Chicago's premier social media marketing agencies since its founding in 2014 by Scott Emalfarb. Located in Evanston, Illinois, the agency has grown from a startup to a team of 33 professionals delivering authentic, data-driven social media strategies.
FCS differentiates itself through its human + AI-powered approach, blending creative storytelling with data-driven insights to produce scalable, high-performing campaigns. Their philosophy centers on treating clients as true partners rather than transactional accounts, delivering platform-specific content that drives real business outcomes.
The agency offers comprehensive services including social media audits, strategy development, content creation, community management, and influencer marketing. Their work has been featured in ADWEEK, CNN, NPR, and Forbes, demonstrating their industry credibility and thought leadership.
Notable success stories include helping Manny's Deli generate a 1,500% sales increase and over 500 million impressions during a challenging period, and creating the #PEAKSquad community that generated over 2 million Instagram Reels views. Their client roster includes KFC, Guitar Center, Adobe, and Death Wish Coffee.
Under founder Scott Emalfarb's leadership, FCS has maintained its commitment to organic social media marketing excellence. The agency's focus on building world-class communities that drive business growth makes them an ideal partner for brands seeking authentic engagement over vanity metrics. Their expertise spans TikTok, Instagram, YouTube, LinkedIn, and Facebook.
Verified credentials and recognition earned by Fresh Content Society
Verified
This agency has a verified website presence.
LinkedIn Verified
This agency has a verified LinkedIn company page.
Top Rated
This agency has an exceptional AgencyCluster score of 80+.
10+ Years
Established in 2014. Over 10 years of experience.
Small Team
Small (11-50)
Rankings earned on AgencyCluster
Common questions about Fresh Content Society.
Fresh Content Society has earned rankings on 3 AgencyCluster lists: Top 10 Social Media Marketing, Top 50 Social Media Marketing, Top 25 Social Media Marketing. Their highest AgencyCluster Score is 85/100. Rankings are merit-based and determined by evidence across six evaluation pillars — agencies cannot pay for higher positions.
In our evaluation for Social Media Marketing, Fresh Content Society scores 85/100 overall. Their strongest areas are Category Fit, Freshness, Credibility, Proof of Work & Outcomes, Reputation, Delivery Maturity. A high Outcomes score means they have verifiable case studies with measurable results — the most heavily weighted factor in our methodology.
Fresh Content Society was founded in 2014, giving them over a decade of experience in social media marketing. In an industry where many agencies are less than 5 years old, 12+ years of sustained operations signals stability, client retention, and the ability to adapt through multiple technology cycles. Today, the team is small team.
Social media management retainers range from $3K–$15K/month. Content production (photo, video, copywriting) adds $2K–$10K/month. Paid social management (in addition to ad spend) runs $2K–$8K/month. These are industry benchmarks for social media marketing agencies at the level AgencyCluster curates. Actual pricing for Fresh Content Society will depend on project scope, timeline, and complexity — contact the agency directly for a custom quote.
Yes. Fresh Content Society has been vetted and verified by AgencyCluster's editorial team through a rigorous, multi-factor review process. Unlike self-serve directories, AgencyCluster does not accept automated submissions — every agency is evaluated manually before being published. Our vetting covers identity verification (website, LinkedIn, domain age), business legitimacy (years of operation, team size, registered presence), evidence of work (case studies, portfolio, client outcomes), reputation checks across third-party platforms, activeness and freshness of their online presence, and screening for red flags including misconduct, fraud, or misleading claims. Agencies that fail any critical check are not listed. For Fresh Content Society, verified signals include a functioning website, LinkedIn company profile, 12+ years of operating history (founded 2014), 3 earned rankings on curated top lists.
